A Contribution Towards Strategies for Proletarian Revolution in the 21st Century…

March 7, 2009

trotsky 1-     The global economic crisis has hit hard on the lives of the workers and peasants around the world. Poor people are loosing their homes, meager productive resources, their subsistence livelihood and are being deprived of their right to life. Many migrant workers are losing their jobs and are returning to their home countries which have further threatened the survival of their families. On the other hand, global wealth has been accumulated by a handful multi-national corporations (MNCs) creating gaps of astronomical proportions between the have’s and have-not’s. This has created an extra-ordinary revolutionary situation at a global scale, as was predicted by Karl Marx in the Communist Manifesto in 1848.

 

2-     As Marx had predicted, global capitalism (ie imperialism) is going to destroy the productive forces and will impose new wars on the proletariat in the near future in order to overcome the current crisis. But, at this critical moment, the would-be ‘vanguards’ of the proletariat are, divided between the throat-cut rival camps (Maoists Vs Trotskyists) giving free hand to imperialism to further exploit the workers and peasants and to destroy the productive forces created by them.

 

3-     When Comrade Lenin had arrived to Russia from exile in February 1917, he found that the comrades in the Bolshevik Party were confused what to do next. Similarly, the current global crisis has taken both Maoists and Trotskyists by ‘surprise’ as they have become onlookers rather than being proactive to capture the essence of the revolutionary situation for decisive action.

 

4-     The greatest contradiction in Marxist theory is that, from one hand, it is a concentrated expression of all the human knowledge accumulated over centuries; on the other hand, this theory has to be internalized, practiced and mastered by a class that is most backward in terms of awareness, organisation and intellectual capacity. This contradiction led to the formation of rival camps in the international working class movement: a) the Stalinist camp that later became Maoist; and b) the Trotskyist camp.

 

5-     The Maoist Camp advocates the possibility of ‘revolution in a single country’ and adopted a strategy of long-term ‘peoples war’. The Trotskyist camp rejected the possibility of ‘socialism in a single country’ and advocated for October Revolution type peoples insurrection supported by international solidarity of working class.

 

6-     As the productive forces have out-grown the limits set by the capitalist relations of production, decisive confrontation between labour and capital is inevitable. Therefore, there is a historical need for both Maoists and Trotskyists, to sort out their past differences and agree on a common platform to give a death-blow to imperialism during the period of its acute crisis.

 

7-     Both the Trotskyists and Maoists seem to agree on the basic principles of revolutionary Marxism, the only difference is in the field of strategy to achieve the goals. Maoists believe that revolution is possible in a single country, and for this, they believe that the strategy of ‘protracted peoples war’. Trotskyists, on the other hand believe that, under imperialism, where the law of value operates at a global scale, revolution is not possible in a single country and the proletariat must be organized for popular insurrection supported by an international movement/network of workers’ parties. Though, both of these strategies contain some rational grains, but these strategies, implemented in isolation, were not effective to achieve the envisioned goals. This has led to a need for revision of the strategies of both the ‘rival’ camps and develop a new strategy for proletarian revolution for the 21st century.

 

8-     In order to unite the revolutionary workers and peasants globally in their fight against imperialism, Maoists and Trotskyists need to urgently sit together and workout a common strategy and platform for action. Imperialism has developed a thousand strategies to maintain its global exploitative structures and to destroy the struggle of the working class. In this context, the working class also needs to confront imperialism by developing a combination of new, multi-dimensional strategies: popular insurrection, people’s war, formation of the 5th International, using the global media, peace talks and diplomatic maneuvers, boycotting the goods of MNCs, capturing the factories and agricultural products of MNCs, and so on as demanded by the specific context.

 

9-     As the workers and peasants in the south are in a backward situation and don’t have access to education and information, one important strategy could be exchange of revolutionary volunteers to provide conceptual and practical support and exchange information and learning.

 

10- As Maoists and Trotskyists are fighting imperialism in isolation, imperialism has been successful to defeat both the camps one by one (take example of the Philippines, India, Pakistan, Columbia, Turkey and so on). If both of these revolutionary camps get united, imperialism could be defeated within a decade.

 

11- As the objective situation for the overthrow of imperialist exploitation has long been matured, the Maoists and Trotskyists need to understand that their major hurdle is internal: division between the revolutionary forces. When the revolutionary forces reorganize themselves and clarify their strategy, the proletariat will be capable to capture power at a global scale. United, Maoists and Trotskyists have a world to win. If Maoists and Trotskyists remain divided and allow imperialism to escape ‘un-hurt’ from the current global crisis, it will be a historical crime towards the cause of the proletariat. Global proletariat wants to understand two things from the Maoists and Trotskyists:

 

a)              why imperialists of all nations and cultures can work together to exploit labour (for example, G-8, G-20, NATO, ASEAN, SAARC, NAFTA, SAFTA, WTO, etc) and;

b)              why the vanguard of the proletariat cannot do the same to overthrow imperialism with an united front?

 

12-  Taking advantage of the backwardness of Russia, Comrade Lenin’s prolonged illness and the policy differences within the Bolshevik Party (Kamenev – Zinoviev – Bukharin Vs. Leon Trotsky) during the early 1920s, Stalin’s criminal gang captured power in Russia and eliminated not only the best leaders and activists of international working class, but also destroyed the very revolutionary heart of Marxism and Leninism. Global capitalism greatly benefited from Koba’s fratricidal and criminal practices (purges) that contributed to the demoralization of working class around the world. Time has come for both Maoists and Trotskyists to sort out the policy issues of the past and build a truly Global Revolutionary (5th) International by unifying RIM, IMT and the 4th International.

 

 

Workers of all nations unite!

 

Long Live Marxism, Leninism and Permanent Revolution!

 

Develop a global strategy to fight imperialism!

 

Down with petty-bourgeois charlatanism and burocratic nomenklatura in working class movement!

 

Down with the policies of class-cooperation!

Trotsky Grave in Mexico

September 18, 2008

Guru Leon Trotsky

September 18, 2008

Guru Trotsky

September 18, 2008

The flag – Hasiya and Hathauda….

September 16, 2008

YCL close-up

September 16, 2008

Trotskysts and Maoists – Need for collaboration

September 16, 2008

Comments on World Perspectives – 2008

 

http://www.marxist.com/world-perspectives-2008-draft-one.htm
http://www.marxist.com/world-perspectives-2008-draft-two.htm

  

Reading your World Perspectives-2008, I am rather disappointed. You have made a great analysis of the current world situation by reflecting on crisis of capitalism and imperialism, the accumulation of capital and the rise of prices of commodities (food, oil, etc) that’s hitting hard on the proletariat. But, you are quite shallow on developing a strategy on how the revolutionary proletariat will be organized and act / respond to that situation.

 

The world situation definitely is growing to an imminent crisis. But, the question is: what is our response to that?? What is the response of revolutionaries locally and globally? What type of party is needed to respond to the challenges at hand? Are we building such a revolutionary party? Are we building the necessary alliances? I did not find any answers to these questions in your paper. As Marx said, you have just “interpreted the world in various ways” rather than taking adequate ACTION to change that.

  

Instead, you are expecting agents of imperialism like PPP in Pakistan to take action. You wrote: “We demand the implementation of the original programme of the PPP, a socialist programme based on the expropriation of the landlords and capitalists. We will develop the necessary transitional demands to relate every concrete struggle for advance to the goal of the socialist transformation of society”. Imperialist Lackeys like PPP don’t help the proletariat to emancipate.

  

You said that you have a revolutionary party in Pakistan, The Struggle. You wrote: “The final and most important condition is the existence of a revolutionary organization and leadership. Does this exist in Pakistan? Yes, it does! The Pakistan Marxists represented by The Struggle have grown in strength and influence in recent years. They have conquered one position after another and have succeeded in uniting the overwhelming majority of the militant youth and working class activists around them. They have a strong and growing presence in every region, every nationality and every important city”.

 

Important developments are on the order of the day and our comrades are in a good position to take advantage of them. The battle lines are being drawn ever more clearly: either black reaction or the triumph of the socialist revolution in Pakistan, in India and in the whole subcontinent. Pakistan may well have the honour of being the first country to strike a blow for socialism and light the flame of revolution that will set both Central Asia and the Subcontinent ablaze” ————

  

This all sounds like a self-praise (of a southern NGO leader to digest the funds it received from a northern donor) rather than an honest and critical self-analysis of a truly revolutionary proletarian party!! Being South-Asian, I believe that India and Pakistan will break-up like former USSR (due to huge caste/ethnic discrimination and low level of organization among the working class) rather than be a light-house of socialism in this region. What holds India and also Pakistan so far as nation states is the presence of a brutal feudal-burocratic dictatorship. So, it seems to me, that, Nepal has a better chance to light the flame of revolution in south-Asia first, if the Maoists here developed innovative strategies to launch the campaign and also to keep their party strong and united. One of the problem with Maoist Leadership here in Nepal is that sometimes, they are “more flexible” than needed, and in this regards, a Trotskyist advisory support will be highly valuable.

  

All this once again highlights the cause that I am fighting for: UNIFICATION of all revolutionary forces locally and globally.

  • Let the Maoists and Trotskyists organize comradely meetings all over the world!
  • Let them critically reflect on the experiences of the past, clarify differences!! (Trotsky, Stalin, Kamenev, Zinoviev, Bukharin, Khruschev, Brezhnev, Mao, “Naxalites” in India, Nepal Maoists, North Korea, Cuba, Venezuela, Chile, Peru, RCP USA, 4th International, RIM, Tendency etc & so on)
  • Marx had said that, “practice is the criterion of the truth”. So let’s see in practice whose strategy worked in which context – Maoists or Trotskyists? Permanent Revolution or Long Tern Peoples War!
  • I believe that, if Maoists and Trotskyists are honest to the revolutionary proletariat, such a critical reflection is possible and a new Unified strategy could be formulated and implemented! Why Not??
  • Let them assess the relationship of forces locally and globally and chart-out a roadmap for the Victory of proletariat!!!
  • In a class society, every revolutionary party will have members that come from different classes: proletariat (working class), peasantry, middle class intelligentsia. Therefore, as Lenin said, contradictions and infighting within the party is a given fact. How to transform inter-party struggle is a vital question for success of working class struggle.
  • Maoists (representing the interests of Peasants) and Trotskyists (representing the interests of factory workers, intelligentsia) are just two sides of the same coin.

If Maoists and Trotskyists take up these steps collectively and in a comradely fashion, this will greatly enhance the morale of the international proletariat. Only such action will reflect the revolutionary spirit of the great founders of Marxism.

Young Revolutionaries of Kathmandu

September 15, 2008

Street Vendors in Kathmandu serving the crowds …

September 15, 2008

Comrade Gaurav arrives to attend meeting

September 15, 2008

Comrade Gaurav, who was captured in India during peoples war and released after a couple of years………….arrives for meeting………….


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.